Player Comparison: David Marshall vs. André Onana vs. David Raya vs. Alisson vs. Ederson vs. Manuel Neuer

Compare player statistics for: David Marshall in 2023-24 vs. André Onana in 2023-24 vs. David Raya in 2023-24 vs. Alisson in 2023-24 vs. Ederson in 2023-24 vs. Manuel Neuer in 2023-24, Domestic Leagues.
Show Criteria
Share Results

Search Criteria

Club Competitions
National Team Competitions
Specific Competition
Player 1
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: David Marshall 
Player 2
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: André Onana 
Player 3
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: David Raya 
Player 4
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Alisson 
Player 5
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Ederson 
Player 6
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Manuel Neuer 

Not able to find a particular player? Let us know via our feedback form and we'll do our best to include them!

You have edited your search criteria

or keep editing your search

clear changes

Fetching Results

Stathead spinner


Goalkeeping Table
Playing Time Performance Penalty Kicks
Player Span Nation Pos Squad MP Starts Min 90s GA GA90 SoTA Saves Save% W D L CS CS% PKatt PKA PKsv PKm Save%
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian33332,85831.8481.511248566.9101112927.31072122.2
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38383,42038.0581.5320314674.918614923.777000.0
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32322,88032.0240.75694568.123451650.0321033.3
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28282,52028.0301.071098073.41684828.611000.0
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City33332,78530.9270.87825670.724631030.333000.0
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich23232,05322.8331.45935966.71616626.1321033.3

Advanced Goalkeeping

Advanced Goalkeeping Table
Goals Expected Launched Passes Goal Kicks Crosses Sweeper
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s GA PKA FK CK OG PSxG PSxG/SoT PSxG+/- /90 Cmp Att Cmp% Att (GK) Thr Launch% AvgLen Att Launch% AvgLen Opp Stp Stp% #OPA #OPA/90 AvgDist
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.8487
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.0587111159.20.27+2.2+0.0614951329.0135114031.031.216258.044.6601406.7370.9713.1
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.024215120.40.26-2.6-0.0813837237.196915932.230.79662.547.53294012.2501.5617.9
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.030104128.60.26-0.4-0.016018332.8102014014.124.711633.633.4299134.3321.1417.6
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.927302127.20.30+1.2+0.0411424646.3112013718.327.211436.036.32472510.1501.6217.3
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.833211028.90.28-4.1-0.187315945.977911018.627.79714.426.023183.5311.3617.5

Standard Stats

Standard Stats Table
Playing Time Performance Expected Progression Per 90 Minutes
Player Span Nation Pos Squad MP Starts Min 90s Gls Ast G+A G-PK PK PKatt CrdY CrdR xG npxG xAG npxG+xAG PrgC PrgP PrgR Gls Ast G+A G-PK G+A-PK xG xAG xG+xAG npxG npxG+xAG
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian33332,85831.8000000000.
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38383,42038.0000000500.
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32322,88032.0000000200.
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28282,52028.0000000100.
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City33332,78530.9000000500.
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich23232,05322.8000000100.


Shooting Table
Standard Expected
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Gls Sh SoT SoT% Sh/90 SoT/90 G/Sh G/SoT Dist FK PK PKatt xG npxG npxG/Sh G-xG np:G-xG
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.80000.000.0000
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.00000.000.000000.
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.00000.000.000000.
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.00000.000.000000.
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.90000.000.000000.
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.80000.000.000000.


Passing Table
Total Short Medium Long Expected
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Cmp Att Cmp% TotDist PrgDist Cmp Att Cmp% Cmp Att Cmp% Cmp Att Cmp% Ast xAG xA A-xAG KP 1/3 PPA CrsPA PrgP
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.80
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.01105152172.6271051863327928099.654755997.926766140.400.10.1-0.1335305
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.0800106874.9196911410822823198.738739199.018343941.700.00.10.0030002
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.0984114186.2214341315023823999.659560598.314828551.900.00.00.018005
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.91077123487.3258981757827527699.656057098.223938162.700.10.1-0.1125104
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.875487686.1184481157014014199.341141898.320331764.

Pass Types

Pass Types Table
Pass Types Corner Kicks Outcomes
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Att Live Dead FK TB Sw Crs TI CK In Out Str Cmp Off Blocks
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.80
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.0152112772367416000000110582
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.01068898167710100000080032
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.01141982154380500000098453
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.9123410771574309000000107701
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.8876754122240301000075400

Goal and Shot Creation

Goal and Shot Creation Table
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s SCA SCA90 PassLive PassDead TO Sh Fld Def GCA GCA90 PassLive PassDead TO Sh Fld Def
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.8
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.060.1660000010.03100000
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.040.1231000000.00000000
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.0110.39101000000.00000000
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.970.2352000020.06200000
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.840.1840000000.00000000

Defensive Actions

Defensive Actions Table
Tackles Challenges Blocks
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Tkl TklW Def 3rd Mid 3rd Att 3rd Tkl Att Tkl% Lost Blocks Sh Pass Int Tkl+Int Clr Err
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.8000
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.02020022100.0000002112
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.01110011100.000000185
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.000000010.0100000114
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.900000010.0100000101
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.81110000000001143


Possession Table
Touches Take-Ons Carries Receiving
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Touches Def Pen Def 3rd Mid 3rd Att 3rd Att Pen Live Att Succ Succ% Tkld Tkld% Carries TotDist PrgDist PrgC 1/3 CPA Mis Dis Rec PrgR
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.8
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.01629122415923700162911100.000.0112659943825100109550
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.0109976410603900109900072834421992000106370
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.0119575511445200119500085037132361000407640
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.9128396512632000128311100.000.084737142353000008420
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.8920701893261192011100.000.057129981845000105790

Playing Time

Playing Time Table
Playing Time Starts Subs Team Success Team Success (xG)
Player Span Nation Pos Squad MP Min Mn/MP Min% 90s Starts Mn/Start Compl Subs Mn/Sub unSub PPM onG onGA +/- +/-90 On-Off onxG onxGA xG+/- xG+/-90 On-Off
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian332,8588783.631.8338729011.244348-5-0.16+0.16
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd383,42090100.038.0389038001.585758-1-0.0356.469.1-12.6-0.33
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal322,8809084.232.0329032032.288024+56+1.75+0.7564.822.0+42.8+1.34+0.45
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool282,5209073.728.0289028002.006030+30+1.07-0.4362.535.5+27.0+0.96-0.57
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City332,7858481.430.9338429022.367827+51+1.65+0.0966.828.0+38.7+1.25+0.38
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich232,0538967.122.8238922002.136433+31+1.36-0.2558.123.5+34.6+1.51-0.11

Miscellaneous Stats

Miscellaneous Stats Table
Performance Aerial Duels
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s CrdY CrdR 2CrdY Fls Fld Off Crs Int TklW PKwon PKcon OG Recov Won Lost Won%
David Marshall2023-24sct SCOGKHibernian31.80000800000
André Onana2023-24cm CMRGKManchester Utd38.05001400000104414287.5
David Raya2023-24es ESPGKArsenal32.0200040001000385183.3
Alisson2023-24br BRAGKLiverpool28.0100150000000356275.0
Ederson2023-24br BRAGKManchester City30.95002400000105380100.0
Manuel Neuer2023-24de GERGKBayern Munich22.8100120001010316366.7
If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.