Player Comparison: Naomi Girma vs. Malia Berkely vs. Emily Menges vs. Katie Bowen vs. Jess Carter vs. Estelle Cascarino

Current Search

Compare player statistics for: Naomi Girma in 2024 vs. Malia Berkely in 2024 vs. Emily Menges in 2024 vs. Katie Bowen in 2023-24 vs. Jess Carter in 2023-24 vs. Estelle Cascarino in 2023-24, Domestic Leagues.
Show Criteria
➦ Share Results

Search Criteria

Competitions
Club Competitions
National Team Competitions
Specific Competition
Player 1
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Naomi Girma 
Player 2
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Malia Berkely 
Player 3
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Emily Menges 
Player 4
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Katie Bowen 
Player 5
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Jess Carter 
Player 6
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Estelle Cascarino 

Not able to find a particular player? Let us know via our feedback form and we'll do our best to include them!

Clear All

You have edited your search criteria

or keep editing your search

clear changes

Standard Stats

Standard Stats Table
Playing Time Performance Expected Progression Per 90 Minutes
Player Span Nation Pos Squad MP Starts Min 90s Gls Ast G+A G-PK PK PKatt CrdY CrdR xG npxG xAG npxG+xAG PrgC PrgP PrgR Gls Ast G+A G-PK G+A-PK xG xAG xG+xAG npxG npxG+xAG
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave664625.1000000000.00.00.00.122800.000.000.000.000.000.000.010.010.000.01
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage10108589.5101013001.80.00.20.223500.100.000.100.000.000.190.020.210.000.02
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC111093510.4011000000.00.00.80.993310.000.100.100.000.100.000.080.080.000.08
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale23221,98122.0000000000.30.31.61.92286200.000.000.000.000.000.010.070.090.010.09
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea21191,72319.1011000200.50.50.91.4129250.000.050.050.000.050.020.050.070.020.07
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus23211,88621.0000000200.20.20.60.817107160.000.000.000.000.000.010.030.040.010.04

Shooting

Shooting Table
Standard Expected
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Gls Sh SoT SoT% Sh/90 SoT/90 G/Sh G/SoT Dist FK PK PKatt xG npxG npxG/Sh G-xG np:G-xG
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.10100.00.190.000.0032.20000.00.00.010.00.0
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.51200.00.210.000.0039.70131.80.00.02-0.80.0
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.40100.00.100.000.0012.80000.00.00.020.00.0
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.008450.00.360.180.000.0018.50000.30.30.04-0.3-0.3
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.10400.00.210.000.008.00000.50.50.11-0.5-0.5
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.008337.50.380.140.000.0028.80000.20.20.03-0.2-0.2

Passing

Passing Table
Total Short Medium Long Expected
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Cmp Att Cmp% TotDist PrgDist Cmp Att Cmp% Cmp Att Cmp% Cmp Att Cmp% Ast xAG xA A-xAG KP 1/3 PPA CrsPA PrgP
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.138041392.077872758879096.725326296.6395768.400.00.20.01343128
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.563169790.511543383624325694.933835894.4477860.300.20.3-0.24292035
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.459769785.711976458714015988.139643092.1589859.210.81.8+0.24373033
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.0966115883.419672806826932183.857963790.911118560.001.61.3-1.698512386
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.11232140587.724866810736840890.271576493.613920169.210.91.2+0.14933292
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.01157135085.724458909426630886.471276693.016624069.200.61.1-0.61210371107

Pass Types

Pass Types Table
Pass Types Corner Kicks Outcomes
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Att Live Dead FK TB Sw Crs TI CK In Out Str Cmp Off Blocks
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.141340211100010000038000
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.569766729210281742063112
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.469768413130040000059705
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.01158105410331211057000096613
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.11405132580270694000001232017
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.013501273723301273810101157515

Goal and Shot Creation

Goal and Shot Creation Table
SCA SCA Types GCA GCA Types
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s SCA SCA90 PassLive PassDead TO Sh Fld Def GCA GCA90 PassLive PassDead TO Sh Fld Def
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.171.3670000010.19100000
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.5121.2683010000.00000000
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.480.7780000010.10100000
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.0291.32241021140.18400000
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.1120.63120000010.05100000
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.0351.67264120230.14300000

Defensive Actions

Defensive Actions Table
Tackles Challenges Blocks
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Tkl TklW Def 3rd Mid 3rd Att 3rd Tkl Att Tkl% Lost Blocks Sh Pass Int Tkl+Int Clr Err
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.1864405683.31108208320
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.51411104061154.55853923230
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.4147113081266.74151051024330
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.024202121142360.99191092145780
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.1432917179162564.09186121255611
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.028231311431225.092411131846490

Possession

Possession Table
Touches Take-Ons Carries Receiving
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s Touches Def Pen Def 3rd Mid 3rd Att 3rd Att Pen Live Att Succ Succ% Tkld Tkld% Carries TotDist PrgDist PrgC 1/3 CPA Mis Dis Rec PrgR
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.147056258208604700002911372916210403350
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.576390471273234760100.01100.04781871826220315550
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.4796894483252977962150.0150.052428821762991825491
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.01315176737515778131511872.7327.36294019233322615583220
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.11568151698791869156833100.000.0997500028991211111510875
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.015081177427057661508301653.31343.38164955286617721612103616

Playing Time

Playing Time Table
Playing Time Starts Subs Team Success Team Success (xG)
Player Span Nation Pos Squad MP Min Mn/MP Min% 90s Starts Mn/Start Compl Subs Mn/Sub unSub PPM onG onGA +/- +/-90 On-Off onxG onxGA xG+/- xG+/-90 On-Off
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave64627751.35.16774001.1754+1+0.19+0.406.47.5-1.0-0.20-0.27
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage108588686.79.510869001.50131300.00+0.6816.69.5+7.1+0.75+2.30
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC119358594.410.410901013500.821422-8-0.77-0.7712.218.2-5.9-0.57-0.83
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale231,9818684.722.02290221101.353738-1-0.05-0.0536.629.3+7.2+0.33-0.64
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea211,7238287.019.119891821812.486017+43+2.25-1.2648.716.6+32.1+1.68-0.34
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus231,8868280.621.021892021232.175325+28+1.34-0.6540.020.2+19.8+0.94+0.16

Miscellaneous Stats

Miscellaneous Stats Table
Performance Aerial Duels
Player Span Nation Pos Squad 90s CrdY CrdR 2CrdY Fls Fld Off Crs Int TklW PKwon PKcon OG Recov Won Lost Won%
Naomi Girma2024us USADFWave5.1000110106000325645.5
Malia Berkely2024us USADFCourage9.500010089110007081142.1
Emily Menges2024us USADFBay FC10.400043041070006091242.9
Katie Bowen2023-24nz NZLDFInternazionale22.00001040102120010111211558.3
Jess Carter2023-24eng ENGDFChelsea19.120098191229001137222348.9
Estelle Cascarino2023-24fr FRADFJuventus21.0200236071823020181171356.7
If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.